About The Cape May Cheese Shop

The Cheese Shop is one of Cape Island Food’s newest expansions and gives our customers that hard-to-satisfy cheese fix that pops up early and often. We are located on the Washington Street Mall in Victorian Cape May, NJ, and specialize in high quality cheeses across every category you can imagine.

Try our exotic specialty cheeses that can be hot, sweet or briny, and try one of our aged cheddars that have been hand-crafted to perfection. And if you love soft cheeses, be sure to try one of our specialty bleu cheeses, a creamy brie, mozzarella and more. Looking for the ultimate gift? Try one of our gift boxes or baskets and get a little bit of everything. We offer cheese and charcuterie boards to create the ultimate party tray and our cured meats are the perfect pairing for any cheese we offer.